AA Insurance Wrap-Up: I Gave Up.
Jordan Kelly • 3 November 2024

Lies, Bullshit & Total Disorganisation - AA Insurance & AA Road Service Are the Pits

To anyone considering taking out a policy with AA Insurance, or moving your business to this outfit, I strongly recommend you read this string of debacles I endured with the insurer, and its related (although they seem to claim not to be) entity, AA Road Service.


Here they are. Read them and weep. In reverse chronological order:  This one. And this one. And this one. And . . . yes, wait, there's more . . . this one.


And as if that's not enough to put off even the hardiest of policy holders, there's the string of unrelated unhappy experiences prior to that . . . read about them here and here.


It's not often that my tenacity is exhausted, but - in the case of the AA - they've managed it.


A concluding email from them (they stopped becoming a priority in my world and my coverage some weeks ago; it amounted to throwing good time after bad), didn't specifically say so, but seemed to indicate that:


  • They no longer required me to sign a legal agreement "limiting my expectations" before I could have a direct conversation with a customer complaints person;


  • Their acknowledgement of the fact that my claim didn't "go smoothly" was limited to the glass replacement guy leaving my gate open and that they'd dealt with him (actually I dealt with him, and that issue was utterly dwarfed by the debacle that was directly administered upon me by the AA itself, not the frigging glass guy;


  • They have an internal menu of readily available, template lies to pull out when handling a claim. In this instance, they obviously didn't even read the notes or my previous correspondence or accounts of my phone calls, since the one they pulled out the bag didn't actually make any sense at all:


       "We cannot provide cover for the window regulator (as this failed due to wear and tear),"  they wrote.


If they weren't such scoundrels - giving the insurance industry at large the bad name that some insurers have tried for decades to shake off - it would be funny.


Why? Because the window regulator didn't fail. The window regulator was never part of my claim. Maybe they meant to tick the option above or below from their standard "pull a reason out of our ass" list of claim refusal "reasons".


Gives you a window (pardon the pun) into their standard modus operandi at the AA, doesn't it?


Another Furious AA Customer Asks The Customer to Take Up Their Case


Meantime, a couple of weeks back, I received a submission through the Contact form on The Customer.


A widow from Upper Hutt had been left vehicle-less (for several weeks at the point of reaching out to me) by AA Road Service.


My understanding of the matter is that two years prior to her recently experiencing a flat battery, an AA Road Service mechanic had installed an incorrect battery - which should have lasted a lot longer than it did, and was still under warranty with the AA when it failed.


For reasons that I'll leave between the AA and their stranded-without-a-vehicle policyholder widow, the AA - she says - had ignored her numerous calls regarding the matter and her vehicle lay undrivable at her property.


I do hope she manages to get them to take the appropriate action and get her back on the road. After all, she'd been an AA Road Service member since the 1990s. I was going to give it a crack on her behalf, but some way into the call with her, I realised that I just didn't have the appetite to suddenly become an unpaid advocate for what might be a whole lot more disgruntled AA policy holders out there around New Zealand. For sure, it almost became a full-time job trying to deal with the various disjointed entities of the Automobile Association, on my own behalf. 


Bloody hell. What a joke. Except it's not. Because if you're the one trying to deal with this lot, it's far from funny.

Other News, Reviews & Commentary

by Jordan Kelly 27 July 2026
Fellow Pet Owners & Followers of the Harry Kelly Case . . . and the Collusive Machinations of the Veterinary Sector’s ‘Regulatory’ Environment
by Jordan Kelly 19 July 2026
This Is Harry. Remember His Face, Massey, You Bastards.
by Jordan Kelly 19 July 2026
Jodie Banner, the Information is the Information. Who Do You Need to 'Consult' With, Have It Sanitised By, Re-Engineered By, Strategised By, or Created By, Before You Finally Release Something to Me?
by Jordan Kelly 17 July 2026
The Multiple Hidden Liabilities in Every Massey Referral: What Vets and Pet Owners Need to Know
by Jordan Kelly 15 July 2026
Massey University Council Members: Ya'll Look So Happy. Do You Care that Your 'Massey-Happiness' Certainly Doesn't Extend to those Paying for Your Institution's 'Services'?
by Jordan Kelly 6 July 2026
Is VCNZ Running A Protection Racket to (a) Cover for Licensed Staff It's Mandated to Hold Accountable, or (b) Cover for A Major Veterinary 'Hospital' Operating Its ICU with NO Qualified Veterinarians on its Evening Shifts and Night Shifts, or (c) BOTH? One Month Later . . . VCNZ Won't Answer and Nor Will Massey . . . So What Does that Indicate?
by Jordan Kelly 6 July 2026
Public & Donor Megafunds Not Spent on Fixing the Root Cause of Massey's Veterinary Practices and Ethics Problems. No, No. Spent Working Out How to Shut Me Up About What They Did to My Dog . . . So Other Pet Owners Don't Learn What Goes On At Its 'Companion Animal Hospital'
by Jordan Kelly 4 July 2026
MORAL INJURY OR EQUALLY EVIL? Massey Vet Students on December 1: Were You Deceived . . . or Participants In the Deception? (PART ONE)
by Jordan Kelly 29 June 2026
' Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has. ' - Margaret Mead (And with zero doubt, what's going on at Massey University's Companion Animal 'Hospital' Needs A World of Urgent Change . . . to Stop More Pets Being Subjected to Huxley's House of Veterinary Horrors )
by Jordan Kelly 18 June 2026
Bypassing Managerial Stonewalling at AVBC, AVMA & RCVS to Alert Accreditors' Directors of their Directorial Liability Obligations
Show More