What's Going On With the Culture of Secrecy in NZ Government?
Jordan Kelly • 12 July 2024

Is This Culture Just Something that Labour Cultivated and that Left Office with Them . . . or Is It Broader, More Enduring, and More Insidious Than That?

First we had the revelations (during the tenure of the past government) that Labour was holding "educational" sessions to train government Ministers and relevant personnel in how to skirt around Official Information Act (OIA) requests from the public.


This week brought two further revelations about more facts and findings that have - at Ministerial level - been withheld from the New Zealand public.


According to a Radio New Zealand report, Associate Health Minister Casey Costello received a serious butt-kicking from the Chief Ombudsman and was instructed to apologise for trying to keep tobacco and vaping policy documents secret.


The RNZ coverage states:  "Chief Ombudsman Judge Peter Boshier took the rare step of forcing Costello to apologise to RNZ and to Otago University Professor of Public Health Janet Hoek (NB: the two parties who sought the information under the OIA) for her handling of Official Information Act (OIA) requests.


"In his ruling, Boshier said Costello's actions in withholding the information were 'unreasonable and contrary to law'.


"Costello came under intense scrutiny earlier this year after RNZ revealed that her public statements on tobacco and vaping policy were contradicted by official documents she had sent to health officials." RNZ's background coverage can be found here.


Radio New Zealand revealed how, in late December 2023, RNZ and Hoek made an OIA request, asking for "all documents sent, held or received by Costello relating to tobacco control and vaping policy".


But Costello refused to release any documents.


So RNZ took the matter to the Ombudsman. And the results of his resultant investigation show deep concerns about Costello's decisions, actions and ethics.


The apology she was instructed by the Ombudsman to tender to Radio New Zealand were (in my opinion as author of this blog), insincere, forced, and relied on the only thing she could fall back on by way of an excuse:  lack of attention to detail, lack of any appreciation for the need for thoroughness in her role, and complete incompetency.


But even that doesn't explain her intentional withholding of information from the public and her related decisions to disingenuously and arrogantly avert her Ministerial OIA obligations. Nor her weak attempt to throw an identified staffer under the bus in a subsequent Newstalk ZB interview.


But Wait There's More . . . And It's All In the Course of One Week


Then we had the a group representing concerned members of the teaching profession - New Zealand Teachers Speaking Out with Science (NZTSOS) - reporting that they had just uncovered a Ministry of Health ‘Science and Insights’ report from October 2021, the content of which would challenge the Labour government's claims about the significant risks of Covid-19 transmission in schools and healthcare "settings".


That, in turn, of course, undermines the entire rationale for vaccine mandates in the health and education sectors.

 

But when NZTOS and their medical sector counterpart, New Zealand Doctors Speaking Out with Science (NZDOS), and associated sector workers, had challenged the vaccine mandates in court in March 2022, the Crown witnesses, Chris Hipkins, Rachel Mackay, Dr Ian Town and Dr Ashley Bloomfield, appear to have withheld all knowledge of the report.

 

NZTSOS is now seeking to appeal to the Supreme Court, citing a miscarriage of justice due to these omissions.


Then we had New Zealand First's bringing to the public's attention the "word on the street" (or the word on the water), that (according to a "tweet" by the Party) the interisland ferry, the Aratere, had run aground last month apparently due to some crew member/members not being able to turn off the autopilot button/switch . . . a communication NZ First was roundly condemned for, both by fellow Parliamentarians and the media.


However, a document subsequently leaked to the New Zealand Herald revealed that the cause of the Aratere running aground did, in fact, appear to be that the autopilot button was accidentally pressed and that the crew didn't know how to turn it off.


All this secrecy and the hiding of information is a concerning culture that is obviously a real concern. My suspicion is that it's a culture that's always been there, and that is only now being challenged.


Stay tuned.

Other News, Reviews & Commentary

by Jordan Kelly 4 June 2025
Hey PowerCo: I Do NOT Appreciate You Giving Out My Email Address to Research Companies . . . Especially Those Who Treat YOUR Customers with Utter Contempt (& Spam Them)
by Jordan Kelly 3 June 2025
Why You Should Teach ALL Employees to Value Your Brand
by Jordan Kelly 26 May 2025
Ministry of Social Development Employee Sprays Around A Client's Private Information, then Sends It to A Journalist 
by Jordan Kelly 25 May 2025
Learn the Plays & Ploys of New Zealand Government Agencies to Beat Them At Their Own Sordid Game Since starting 'The Customer & The Constituent' back in January 2024, I've been learning things about the New Zealand political scene as it relates to Ministers and their Ministries (or agencies or bureaus), and also the behind-the-curtain Parliamentary machinations related to them. Things I almost wish now that I didn't know. But they're things that, for better or for worse, ALL New Zealanders should know, about the way the New Zealand Government and its "public service" really operates. If you don't know how things operate in reality (not just the PR fluff on their websites) in some of these big-name agencies that we are forced to deal with in one way or another, at some time or another, depending on the need or issue you're attempting to have solved or resolved, you could go around in ever-increasing frustrating circles for weeks, months and even years. Before getting absolutely nowhere . And the worst part is: That's the intention . The 5 D's 1) Delay 2) Defer 3) Deny 4) Defend 5) Dismissed They're largely self-explanatory, but it's an absolute playbook that they stick to, and apparently senior agency bureaucrats and Ministers and their staff are taught this as a rite of passage into parliamentary and career public "roles" . . . and then are sworn to secrecy over it, in a manner that almost has "Eyes Wide Shut" secret society overtones to it. You NEVER refer to the '5 D's' outside of the walls of inner sanctums. However, I'd add two more "D"s to their list: The sixth: Deaf (as in, Ignore). The seventh: Dumb .. And oh my goodness, let me count the ways (which I will do in further articles in this Series, in specific, detailed and named examples). So between your introduction herein to the 'D's', and my ongoing and, I hope, enlightening, series for your continuing and essential edification regarding How Wellington Really Works, I trust that you'll end up knowing how to deal with this sordid scene in a more strategic manner, for a less infuriating time, and maybe even with an outcome. Although there's no guarantee that any "outcome" won't be no outcome. Because that's almost always their intention. Oh, and I do hope that my pieces actually do become an ongoing series, because they do "hit men" (of sorts), too. Yeah, really. Paid generously (with your money, by the way) to "remove" "difficult" ( their words; not mine) individuals. Like me. Stay tuned. See you again shortly. I hope. (PS: I think a feel a book coming on.) COMING NEXT : A drill-down on each of the 'D's. And next up after that: The detailed argument I'll put to the private sector on why hiring an ex-bureaucrat is a very bad idea ( Hint: You might think it gives you in-house lobbyist power and back-door influence, but the price you'll pay is the '5D' customer service anti-culture they'll foster throughout your organisation. Even IF you keep them away from the frontline, it will happen by osmosis anyway. And faster than you think. The worst part? The longer you keep them, the more irreversible the damage they'll seed in your culture. Which then hits your brand. And so on. So, to C-suites everywhere, this will be a read you NEED .
by Jordan Kelly 25 May 2025
Thousands Sign Up to 'Better Wellington' Movement, Seeking Urgent Cessation to Unaffordable Rates, Economic Decay and 'Wrong Direction' of City Council
by Jordan Kelly 20 May 2025
To the Silly Old Placard-Waving (& Terrorist-Supporting) Fools . . . As Seen Daily On the Corner of Chapel & Perry Streets in Masterton
by Jordan Kelly 18 May 2025
** READERS: SEE UPDATE AT END OF ARTICLE. - The Ed. ** Dear MDC Management, Do You Have Any Standards for Your Call Centre Contractors?
by Jordan Kelly 15 May 2025
Being Known As the Woman Who Introduced 'C---' into the New Zealand Parliament, Wasn't A Smart Long-Term Strategy
by Jordan Kelly 14 May 2025
Cheap Trumps Standards, Ethics & Compassion . . . Apparently
by Jordan Kelly 13 May 2025
A Massive Upside IF It's Done Right . . . and An Unrecoverable Downside It It's Not
Show More