PM Luxon's Ban on Mobile Phones in Schools Is A Smart Idea in More Ways Than One
Jordan Kelly • 16 May 2024

Digital Tech & Education - Part One

Guest contributor and expert on Electromagnetic Pollution and its health effects, EMR Australia founder Lyn McLean, provides authoritative insight into why banning the use of cell phones in NZ schools is a smart idea for kids' health in far more ways than those making that wise decision, probably realised.


Digital Tech & Education – Part 1 (of A Two-Part Series)
 
Digital technology is everywhere in education:  in classrooms, in students’ pockets, on their laps, in their ears, in their homes.


Does that mean it’s benefiting their learning?


Not according to Professor Tom Butler from the University College of Cork in Ireland.


In his recent paper that reviews the latest research in neuroscience, cognitive psychology and education, Professor Butler says, "It is now apparent that digital technology has a 'dark side' with negative consequences for society that often outweigh the benefits that it brings."


This is concerning, given that children and teens are spending so long – up to 12 hours a day – on digital devices, at school, at home, and everywhere else they go. Moreover, they are often exposed to multiple devices at once.


Professor Butler explains that there are many reasons why digital technology is harmful – and not just for learning.
 

Sleep Problems


All screens contain LEDs [Light-Emitting Diodes] that emit artificial light frequencies that disrupt the body’s circadian rhythms and interfere with sleep. This can have negative consequences for the user, as sleep is important for memory and learning – as well as for health.


Butler says that "short-term sleep deprivation . . . affects cognition, vigilance, mood, behaviour, ability to learn, immune function, and general performance. Moreover, epidemiological studies associate poor sleep with long-term outcomes such as diabetes, obesity, depression, hypertension, and general mortality from all causes."


Lack of sleep has also been linked to substance abuse in teens.
 

Vision Problems


Digital device use also has negative effects on vision.


According to Butler, "LED and CD screen design features such as refresh rate, luminance contrast levels, fluctuating light, backlighting, and contrast contribute to eye strain and visual fatigue – this has become known as Computer Vision Syndrome (CVS)."


CVS can negatively affect legibility and comprehension and even contribute to the loss of retinal cells and macular degeneration.
 

Keys vs Pens


Professor Butler says that it’s pens, pencils and paper – not keys and keyboards – that give the best results when it comes to learning and remembering – and he provides the evidence:


  • There are intellectual benefits from physically writing letters and words. According to Butler, "The act of writing plays a pivotal role in learning. Typing keys on a keyboard does not have the same effect. Writing and typing involve different cognitive-neurological processes and outcomes in terms of neural circuitry."


  • Multiple studies have found that university students perform better in exams when they take notes by hand rather than using a laptop.


  • Students who use computers in class learn less well and disrupt the learning of others.


  • People learn better when reading from paper rather than online texts. The reading of digital texts tends to result in more superficial processing and reduced comprehension.


Attention Problems


The use of digital devices adversely affects attention and learning.


When students use digital devices in classrooms, it doesn’t mean they’re learning.


Butler refers to studies showing that digital devices increase student distraction and says that students who use them are more likely to be off-task during lectures – perhaps checking their phones or scrolling on the internet.


Multitasking, in other words.


"Multi-tasking is epidemic in the digital age," he says.


However, the human brain is not built to multi-task efficiently and only 2% of the population can actually do it.


"Although people might think they’re multi-tasking efficiently, each time a person switches from one activity to another, they’re paying a price in cognition."


In Part 2, Guest Contributor Lyn McLean will write about the harmful effects of digital technology on the brain itself, together with Professor Butler’s suggestions on how to mitigate risks.


Reference:  Butler, T. (2024, March 29). A Critical Review of Digital Technology in Education: A Pause for Thought in 2024. SocArXiv https://doi.org/10.31235/osf.io/5q8vg

 

 

Other News, Reviews & Commentary

by Jordan Kelly 4 June 2025
Hey PowerCo: I Do NOT Appreciate You Giving Out My Email Address to Research Companies . . . Especially Those Who Treat YOUR Customers with Utter Contempt (& Spam Them)
by Jordan Kelly 3 June 2025
Why You Should Teach ALL Employees to Value Your Brand
by Jordan Kelly 26 May 2025
Ministry of Social Development Employee Sprays Around A Client's Private Information, then Sends It to A Journalist 
by Jordan Kelly 25 May 2025
Learn the Plays & Ploys of New Zealand Government Agencies to Beat Them At Their Own Sordid Game Since starting 'The Customer & The Constituent' back in January 2024, I've been learning things about the New Zealand political scene as it relates to Ministers and their Ministries (or agencies or bureaus), and also the behind-the-curtain Parliamentary machinations related to them. Things I almost wish now that I didn't know. But they're things that, for better or for worse, ALL New Zealanders should know, about the way the New Zealand Government and its "public service" really operates. If you don't know how things operate in reality (not just the PR fluff on their websites) in some of these big-name agencies that we are forced to deal with in one way or another, at some time or another, depending on the need or issue you're attempting to have solved or resolved, you could go around in ever-increasing frustrating circles for weeks, months and even years. Before getting absolutely nowhere . And the worst part is: That's the intention . The 5 D's 1) Delay 2) Defer 3) Deny 4) Defend 5) Dismissed They're largely self-explanatory, but it's an absolute playbook that they stick to, and apparently senior agency bureaucrats and Ministers and their staff are taught this as a rite of passage into parliamentary and career public "roles" . . . and then are sworn to secrecy over it, in a manner that almost has "Eyes Wide Shut" secret society overtones to it. You NEVER refer to the '5 D's' outside of the walls of inner sanctums. However, I'd add two more "D"s to their list: The sixth: Deaf (as in, Ignore). The seventh: Dumb .. And oh my goodness, let me count the ways (which I will do in further articles in this Series, in specific, detailed and named examples). So between your introduction herein to the 'D's', and my ongoing and, I hope, enlightening, series for your continuing and essential edification regarding How Wellington Really Works, I trust that you'll end up knowing how to deal with this sordid scene in a more strategic manner, for a less infuriating time, and maybe even with an outcome. Although there's no guarantee that any "outcome" won't be no outcome. Because that's almost always their intention. Oh, and I do hope that my pieces actually do become an ongoing series, because they do "hit men" (of sorts), too. Yeah, really. Paid generously (with your money, by the way) to "remove" "difficult" ( their words; not mine) individuals. Like me. Stay tuned. See you again shortly. I hope. (PS: I think a feel a book coming on.) COMING NEXT : A drill-down on each of the 'D's. And next up after that: The detailed argument I'll put to the private sector on why hiring an ex-bureaucrat is a very bad idea ( Hint: You might think it gives you in-house lobbyist power and back-door influence, but the price you'll pay is the '5D' customer service anti-culture they'll foster throughout your organisation. Even IF you keep them away from the frontline, it will happen by osmosis anyway. And faster than you think. The worst part? The longer you keep them, the more irreversible the damage they'll seed in your culture. Which then hits your brand. And so on. So, to C-suites everywhere, this will be a read you NEED .
by Jordan Kelly 25 May 2025
Thousands Sign Up to 'Better Wellington' Movement, Seeking Urgent Cessation to Unaffordable Rates, Economic Decay and 'Wrong Direction' of City Council
by Jordan Kelly 20 May 2025
To the Silly Old Placard-Waving (& Terrorist-Supporting) Fools . . . As Seen Daily On the Corner of Chapel & Perry Streets in Masterton
by Jordan Kelly 18 May 2025
** READERS: SEE UPDATE AT END OF ARTICLE. - The Ed. ** Dear MDC Management, Do You Have Any Standards for Your Call Centre Contractors?
by Jordan Kelly 15 May 2025
Being Known As the Woman Who Introduced 'C---' into the New Zealand Parliament, Wasn't A Smart Long-Term Strategy
by Jordan Kelly 14 May 2025
Cheap Trumps Standards, Ethics & Compassion . . . Apparently
by Jordan Kelly 13 May 2025
A Massive Upside IF It's Done Right . . . and An Unrecoverable Downside It It's Not
Show More